Fix the broken windows

Stopping the small violations will hopefully eradicate the bigger issues.

 
 
This is the description of the media involved in the media container above.

Have you ever heard of the Broken Windows Theory? Well, even if you have, bear with me for a moment. The theory states that if you have an abandoned building with a broken window the likelihood of vandals breaking a few more windows is quite high.

And, that if you ignore the problem long enough, soon all the windows will be broken and the building may soon become a den for unlawful behaviour. The idea is to fix the broken windows to prevent the escalation of crime related to that building. This is a simplified version of the theory but I think you get the general idea.

New York City employed the tenets expounded in this theory when trying to tackle escalating crime in the early 1990s. City authorities started small by stopping fare evaders in the subway system. Then they started to paint over graffiti. Seemingly small issues such as loitering, public urination, etc were all tackled and the crime rate within the city dropped significantly. The reasons for the decline have been hotly debated but the Broken Windows Theory seems to have been a contributor in some form, so much so that other cities across the US have implemented it with similar success. Albuquerque Police Department's Safe Streets Program helped curtail crime and make its roads a safer place by using the basics of the Broken Window Theory.

And how, hopefully, you can see where I'm going.

We are inundated with letters on a daily basis by readers complaining about the disorder on South Africa's roads. We read stories of incorrect indicator use, people with no consideration for fellow motorists, road hogs, taxi drivers with no understanding for the road rules, etc. In the past we have seen taxis scooting down the emergency lane to gain a few places in a traffic queue, or drive through an orange light at high speed. This was confined to taxi drivers, but increasingly "regular" motorists seem to emulate this behaviour because there seems to be no discernible penalty for such transgressions.

This is my suggestion; start with the small violations. Nail every single driver using his/her cellphone illegally. Fine anyone that does not use an indicator. If you stop in the middle of an intersection, which is unlawful even if the traffic light is green, you need to be fined. Place cameras at EVERY major intersection to mete out fines for those that choose to shoot through red lights. Lane straddling, driving continuously in the fast lane, driving too slow on a freeway - issue fines for all these smaller issues.

Theoretically, people will be less inclined to commit larger offences if these smaller ones are heavily policed and dealt with severely. Well, that's the idea anyway. Tackling the "broken windows" will ideally have the effect of reversing the steadily declining quality of driving on local roads.

Topics In This Article

City: New York City
Country: United States

Comments

Yes, the 'Broken window' theory works, but it requires the political will to implement in practice. Is there sufficient political will to implement it in practice in any of the provinces in SA? Certainly not in KZN, where 'Zero tolerance' is a term nobody bothers to use anymore either.
Posted by: Merlin77
To enable the authorities to enforce the law they have to understand it themselves. I think the reason speed trapping is so prolific is the enforcers don't know any other sections of the Act. Politicians are keen to be seen and heard, but thereafter fall into the mindset that some-one else will take the idea and run with it. Stratigise, vocalise, impliment. Take a leaf out of Robin Carlisle's book (CAR Safety Award pg 54 3-2010). I've long upheld the belief that road fatalities & accidents are caused by stupidity & arrogance, NOT SPEED. Observe the guardians of the fast lane, inconsiderate driving etc. Enforce the law in towns & cities and watch the benefits filter through to highway motoring. All too often parents drive with unfettered children in the car (preserve them - they have your surname & didn't ask to be born. Progressing through life they will be a mirror image of your stupidity), cellphone obsession, etc, etc. Enforce, penalise & educate & our generation's kids might just make it.
Posted by: David H
This will NEVER happen in SA because the authorities themselves are the cocks of the walk.
Posted by: André
You've put into words exactly what I have been thinking. As an example, I don't know that anyone uses an indicator anymore and when confronted, they think you're nuts for suggesting that they should. Inconsiderate driving is in large due to selfish behaviour which extends beyond driving. A mindset change is required (unlikely) or harsh penalties to dissuade (one can only hope).
Posted by: Eckhardt

Add a Comment

All comments must be approved by our CAR editors. Please allow some time for moderation before you will see your comment on the website.
* Required fields
  *
  *
 
  *
Verification Image   *
Submit Comment >
Cancel Comment

Featured Car: Saab 9-3 Sport Sedan Linear 1.9 TiD Dsl

Saab 9-3 Sport Sedan Linear 1.9 TiD Dsl

CAR-Guide Page:

Saab 9-3 Sport Sedan Linear 1.9 TiD Dsl  view >
 

Latest Articles:

Saab 9-3
Galleries | Photo Gallery

Saab 9-3

Published 11 Feb 08
 

Related Content

 

Most Popular Blogs

A motoring journalist's guide to flying

A motoring journalist's guide to flying
As some of you may know, I've just returned from a two-week break on the Russian...      
 

100 Years of Alfa Romeo

100 Years of Alfa Romeo
On June 24 Alfa Romeo turned 100 years old, a feat remarkable not only for the obvious...      
 

A tale of new heroes and a brainless has-been

A tale of new heroes and a brainless has-been
Silverstone victor Mark Webber voiced dissatisfaction with his team in no uncertain...      
 

SLS cleared for take-off

SLS cleared for take-off
Mercedes-Benz all-new supersports car has debuted in SA, and we drive the model on...      
 

Latest in Blogs

Lifan cars

Lifan cars
Ex Mini Tritec engine finds its way into Chinese Lifan 520      
 

Doing it for the team - not

Doing it for the team - not
Along with millions of other race fans around the world, I was aghast when I heard Rob...      
 

Walter's cruise missile

Walter's cruise missile
The new Porsche 911 GT2 RS owes its existence to a test day at the Nurburgring back in...      
 

To Rapide or not to Rapide

To Rapide or not to Rapide
Since the Aston Martin Rapide test car featured in the August issue of CAR magazine...      
 
MORE
 
 

CAR Blogs

Lifan cars

CAR magazine  Ex Mini Tritec engine finds its way into Chinese Lifan 520
 

Doing it for the team - not

John Bentley Along with millions of other race fans around the world, I was aghast when I heard Rob Smedley, Felipe Massa's engineer, passing on the thinly-veiled order to give way...  
 

Walter's cruise missile

John Bentley The new Porsche 911 GT2 RS owes its existence to a test day at the Nurburgring back in 2007, when Porsche's racing division gave Walter Roehrl a special car to try.  
 

To Rapide or not to Rapide

Hannes Oosthuizen Since the Aston Martin Rapide test car featured in the August issue of CAR magazine left our offices, I've spent a great many nights rolling around in bed, getting...  
 

From now on, call us Motorheads

Stuart Johnston The biggest challenge us….uuhh….petrolheads face in the next decade is the Coming of the Electric car. Or maybe that should be the second coming.
 
more >
 
SUBSCRIBE to our weekly newsletter for latest news!
 
BACK TO TOP
© Copyright 2009 All Rights Reserved. CARmag.co.za is designed, maintained and hosted by RamsayMedia.
SITE TRAFFIC | PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS OF USE | COPYRIGHT | CONTACT US | AD RATES | WEBSITE CREDITS
 
sq:0.137 0.696s - 153pq - 3rq